Hey ragnog, GZ to your drop. I am looking forward to get it myself soon (please?), since we are raiding Erlik every week and downed the first two bosses during the last two weeks.
I would like to know, what specc you are running atm. I am testing Claws of the Reaper since monday and I parsed 1070 to 1100 DPS with my T2 blunt and my (nearly, missing helmet) full Tiger set. This was a little improvement to my old specc (with 4 points in Balance of Nature and two in Weight of the World).
I will keep the testing up, so far I can say: CotR > CoC, but I need further testing to see, if CotR weighs out WotW.
It has awesome looks, I agree! However I think it is missing some stat, the overall dps is even lower than even the Tier 3 weapon, unless this is another healing wand. If they would add some str, or perhaps crit dmg rating it would be worth to have instead of the T3.5 one.